I once heard that The Coca-Cola Company decided to stop advertising the Coke brand a few years ago. According to the story, the thinking was that advertising wasn't necessary if the beverage truly was only "an arm's reach away" all over the world.
So, they stopped advertising. And sales went down. But why? You can't get much more ingrained in people's consciousness than Coke - or be more ubiquitous. So how could advertising really affect sales?
In the case of a brand like Coke I think it's because people not only want it to be ingrained into the fabric of their lives but they also want to LIKE or LOVE the brand for the way it expresses itself - and now, to literally interact with it. It seems advertising can increase that effect by several multiples. And it also seems, as you might suspect, that good advertising (defined as advertising that creates increased emotional resonance, engagement and sales) is even better at doing it.
So the question is, does The Coca-Cola Company want to sell more Diet Coke?
Judging by the advertising, no.
Because a beverage like Diet Coke that is consumed as if it were a religion, as addictive and as necessary to many daily routines as cigarettes, coffee or vodka, could certainly do advertising that is more emotionally resonant, engaging and impactful than "Stay Extraordinary."
If you are like millions of other people you drink Diet Coke. But can you name the last Diet Coke ad, app or program you saw? Can you say whether or not you liked it, or loved it? Can you recall, vaguely, the vibe you get from the way Diet Coke expresses itself?
I don't know the strategic thinking behind the work. Having worked on the brand a while ago I do know that they've struggled for years to capture its essence in the way "Open Happiness" has for Coke. Too worried about "intrinsic" and "extrinsic" blah, blah, blah. Simply start with Diet Coke being an essential ingredient in millions of daily lives. Creating ideas that spring from that truth could lead to fun, engaging, useful, loved conversations with the world. And sell more Diet Coke.